ANALYSIS
A chaotic debate in New York: Mamdani dodges criticism, Cuomo plays the victim, and Sliwa makes a mockery of himself
Tonight's debate is unlikely to impact the state of the race, where the socialist candidate remains the clear favorite.
A collage of the three New York City mayoral candidates
The first New York City mayoral debate, held at Rockefeller Center, left a clear sense of disorder, marked by personal attacks and impossible promises from the candidates. The three onstage—democratic socialist Zohran Mamdani, former governor Andrew Cuomo (now running as an independent), and Republican Curtis Sliwa—offered starkly different visions for the city but agreed on one thing tonight: political spectacle prevailed over serious debate.
Mamdani, a heavy favorite in the polls, appeared confident in his campaign but evasive in the face of criticism. He failed to explain, for example, how he would fund the $10 billion price tag of his ambitious package of subsidies— which includes universal child care, free public transit, and a rent freeze—without raising taxes. When moderators pressed him, the young assemblyman answered with empty formulations lacking economic grounding: “We have also put forward a plan to save money here in New York,” he said, without offering concrete figures. His lack of clarity reinforced criticisms that his economic program is, at least for now, more ideological than realistic.
On public safety, the socialist candidate insisted on reforming the NYPD and stripping the commissioner of disciplinary power, but the issue boomeranged when former Governor Cuomo brought up his 2020 tweets calling the police “racist” and a “threat to public safety.” “Respect the police. They’re not racists,” the former governor said, in one of the night’s most tense moments. Mamdani hit back, invoking Cuomo’s handling of the pandemic: “As much as Cuomo wants to bring up tweets from 2020—when he himself was sending seniors to their deaths in nursing homes—I am looking to work with police officers, not to defund the NYPD.”
Cuomo, for his part, tried at all costs to present himself as the candidate of experience, but his defense sounded strained when he addressed past sexual harassment allegations. Throughout the night, the former governor attacked Mamdani, who more than once took the bait and got bogged down with his rival in long, disorganized stretches of the debate.
Sliwa, meanwhile, sought to set himself apart with a provocative style. He said he “looked mayoral” and “acted mayoral,” but his focus on secondary topics and personal anecdotes—such as having been shot in a taxi—came off more like entertainment than governance.
After two hours of clashes, the debate’s takeaway was clear: Mamdani failed to dispel doubts about his viability, Cuomo couldn’t shake his reputation, and Sliwa again looked like a symbolic candidacy in an overwhelmingly Democratic city.
Sliwa leaves the debate satisfied: “I looked mayoral”
Exiting the studio, Republican candidate Curtis Sliwa sounded confident about his performance: “I looked mayoral,” he said. “I acted mayoral. I obviously had to get my words in edgewise, because you had two kids in the schoolyard who just wanted to continue their battles from the primary.”
Cuomo’s team touts his readiness—and hits Mamdani
Bill Mulrow, chair of Andrew Cuomo’s campaign, said the former governor showed he’s the strongest candidate and “capable of doing the job on day one.” He added that Mamdani wants to “tax New Yorkers into becoming ex-New Yorkers.”
Mamdani offers no pro-business signals to attract investment
Pressed on how he’d persuade companies—especially tech firms—to pick an expensive city over cheaper destinations like Texas, Zohran Mamdani avoided promising incentives or tax breaks. He focused instead on “quality of life” and “safety” as anchors for the private sector: “As mayor… I will deliver that quality of life… and ensure that companies choose to come to this city and also choose to stay.” His parallel plan to raise the corporate tax rate by 3% has stirred concern among business leaders.
Mamdani does not endorse Governor Hochul, even though she did
Asked whether they would support Kathy Hochul’s reelection, none raised a hand. Though Mamdani said, “I do think that Kathy Hochul has been doing a good job,” he again postponed an explicit endorsement: “It’s a decision that should be made after this general election.” Cuomo pressed him—“Why won’t you endorse her?”—without success. The detail matters: parts of Mamdani’s $10 billion social package would need Albany’s help.
Mamdani attempts to sidestep the controversy over the legalization of prostitution and petty crimes
Cuomo accused Mamdani of pushing “legalization of prostitution” and of not wanting to enforce misdemeanors, warning of quality-of-life effects. Mamdani pushed back with two verbatim clarifications: “I want to be very clear. Not only have I never called for the legalization of prostitution, I’m not calling for that today.”
“And I have never said anything about not enforcing misdemeanors. This is yet another invention of Andrew Cuomo,” he added.
Context: Mamdani co-sponsored sex-work decriminalization measures (Cecilia’s Law, removing penalties for selling or buying sex while maintaining penalties for trafficking). On misdemeanors, he distanced himself from the DSA plank calling to eliminate them; Cuomo tried to tie him to that platform.
Mamdani says Cuomo isn’t qualified to be mayor because he never visited a mosque
In a striking exchange, Zohran Mamdani argued Andrew Cuomo is not qualified to lead the city because he failed to visit a single mosque as governor.
“He had over 10 years and he couldn’t name a single mosque that he visited… Muslims want equality and respect!”
“Name a single mosque you went to when governor… You couldn’t visit a mosque.”
Mamdani doubles down on stripping NYPD commissioner’s disciplinary power
Zohran Mamdani stood firm on shifting final disciplinary authority from the NYPD commissioner to the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB).
“I think it’s time to remove much of the politics out of the question of accountability,” he said, arguing CCRB recommendations too often face political pressure and aren’t followed through.
He framed the move as a more transparent system for New Yorkers.
Sliwa hammers Cuomo with family comparison: ‘You are no Mario Cuomo’
Republican Curtis Sliwa delivered one of the night’s sharpest personal hits, claiming Cuomo’s parole board released 43 cop killers.
“You are no Mario Cuomo,” he said, invoking the late former governor and Andrew Cuomo’s father.
The line drew a reaction in the room and reinforced Sliwa’s law-and-order branding.
Cuomo again hits Mamdani over calling the NYPD ‘racist’
Andrew Cuomo revisited Zohran Mamdani’s 2020 posts labeling the NYPD “racist” and a “threat to public safety.”
“Respect the police. They’re not racists,” Cuomo shot back. “As the assemblyman calls them, they’re not a threat to public safety… They are here to protect New Yorkers.”
Mamdani countered: “I’ve been clear time and time again… I’m looking to work with police officers, not to defund the NYPD.”
Cuomo blasts Mamdani’s ‘freeze the rent’ plan
Former governor Andrew Cuomo tore into Mamdani’s signature proposal to freeze rents, calling it a half-measure.
“Freeze the rent only postpones the rent,” Cuomo said, arguing it wouldn’t fix structural housing issues and wouldn’t help tenants and homeowners outside the rent-stabilized system.
The clash underscored a wider ideological divide: Mamdani pushes tighter controls; Cuomo argues for development and delivery capacity.
Mamdani fails to explain how to fund $10B in “freebies” without tax hikes
Democratic socialist Zohran Mamdani repeatedly dodged the key question of how he would pay for $10 billion in new benefits without raising taxes, even as Gov. Kathy Hochul has ruled out income-tax increases.
“Look, a lot of people even called my campaign a non-starter… and now I stand before you proud to be the Democratic nominee who got the most votes in city primary history,” he said—offering no specifics.
Pressed again, he added only: “We have also put forward a plan to save money here in New York City.” The evasive exchange sharpened doubts about the fiscal viability of his agenda.
Cuomo questions Mamdani for not supporting Harris in the primary
Cuomo attacked Mamdani for promoting the “leave it blank” campaign during the Democratic presidential primary instead of supporting Kamala Harris. “You’re not a Democrat!” Cuomo shouted during the exchange.
Mamdani defended himself, saying: “I said ‘leave it blank’ in the presidential primary because primaries are our space to express dissent,” before turning to talk about the “genocide” of Palestinians.
Mamdani reports just $2,000 in bank account
In his latest financial disclosures, Zohran Mamdani reported having only $2,000 in the bank, despite earning $131,000 a year as a state lawmaker. The 33-year-old socialist did list four acres of land in Uganda, valued between $150,000 and $250,000, but no U.S. properties or investments.
No candidate backs NYPD-National Guard cooperation
When asked whether they would allow the NYPD to work with the National Guard if deployed by the president, none of the three candidates raised their hands. The question followed Trump’s renewed threats to send federal troops into New York, as he has done in other cities.
Cuomo vs. Mamdani over Hamas
Cuomo went after Mamdani over his stance on Israel and Gaza, accusing him of refusing to explicitly condemn Hamas: “The assemblyman will not denounce Hamas.” He also said Mamdani “does not recognize Israel’s right to exist as a Jewish state,” and linked him to slogans like “from the river to the sea.”
Cuomo cast Mamdani as “radical” on foreign policy and pulled the exchange’s focus toward the Middle East—an especially sensitive arena in a city where relations with the White House and potential federal cutbacks loom over the campaign.
Minutes later, when pressed by the moderators, Mamdani clarified his position on Hamas: “Of course, I believe they should lay down their arms.” The answer appeared aimed at limiting political damage as both candidates court moderate voters.
Trump takes center stage at NYC mayoral debate
President Donald Trump quickly became the focal point of New York City’s mayoral debate, as the three candidates were pressed on how they would deal with his administration amid threats to cut federal funding to the city.
Democrat Zohran Mamdani said he would “work with the president” if it helps lower the cost of living but accused Trump of using power to “prosecute political opponents” and push mass deportations.
Independent Andrew Cuomo struck a more measured tone, recalling their clashes during the pandemic and vowing to “work together where possible, but fight back if he tries to hurt New York.”
Republican Curtis Sliwa urged direct cooperation with the president, supporting the Gateway Tunnel project but calling the Q train extension “unnecessary.”
Sliwa seeks contrast and outsider appeal
Republican Curtis Sliwa began his appearance emphasizing his outsider status and noting it was his first time debating both Mamdani and Cuomo. Without his trademark red beret, he aimed to draw contrasts and appeal to disaffected voters in a city overwhelmingly dominated by Democrats.
Cuomo emphasizes experience and defends his record
Former governor Andrew M. Cuomo, running as an independent, opened by stressing that management experience is essential for leadership, warning that “failed mayors are the ones with no management experience.” He also defended his record, claiming there was “no basis” for reports that he sexually harassed women during his tenure.
Mamdani opens with campaign message
Democrat and Socialist Zohran Mamdani opened the debate by reiterating his core theme: taking on President Trump and delivering on affordability. He said the headline of his mayoral legacy would read “Mamdani Continues to Take on Trump, Delivers on Affordability.” His opening statement set a progressive tone and positioned him against both rivals.
Context of the race: who's who and what's at stake.
Assemblyman Zohran Mamdani, 33, is the most notable face of a new generation of left-leaning politicians in New York. The son of Ugandan immigrants of Indian descent and self-declared socialist, he has generated enthusiasm among young voters and the progressive grassroots, but also unease among business and moderate sectors of the Democratic Party. His agenda proposes a rent freeze, free day care, free public transportation and a thorough restructuring of the NYPD, measures that his critics describe as unfeasible or radical.
Former Gov. Andrew Cuomo, seeking a political comeback after resigning in 2021 over sexual harassment allegations, is trying to portray himself as the only candidate with real executive experience capable of balancing finances and tackling the housing crisis. Ousted from the Democratic primaries, he now competes as an independent, with the challenge of cleaning up his image and attracting the moderate voter who distrusts Mamdani.
Republican Curtis Sliwa, a figure known for founding the citizen patrol group Guardian Angels, focuses his discourse on security and order, proposing to add 7,000 police officers and reverse criminal reform laws. Although he faces a structural disadvantage in a city with six Democrats for every Republican, his direct tone and media presence keep him on the radar.
Tonight's debate will be key in defining whether Mamdani consolidates his lead or if Cuomo manages to regain ground with a strategy of direct contrast. The most recent polls show him with more than 40% voting intention, followed by Cuomo and, at a distance, Sliwa.
In minutes the debate kicks off. Meet the moderators
The event takes place at Rockefeller Center, moderated by David Ushery and Melissa Russo(NBC 4), Rosarina Bretón (Telemundo 47) and Sally Goldenberg (Politico). It is the first of two meetings before the Nov. 4 election.
Mamdani arrived accompanied by music
Democratic front-runner Zohran Mamdani walked the six blocks from Trump Tower to Rockefeller Plaza alongside a brass band in a symbolic staging against President Donald Trump. "We're not just standing up to Donald Trump, we're standing up to the entire system that created him, the same system that also gave us Andrew Cuomo," he told supporters
Cuomo arrives at the building
Former Gov. Andrew Cuomo arrived at 30 Rockefeller Plaza after his rivals' supporters had already left. He assured reporters that his goal in the debate is "for New Yorkers to hear the truth."
Expectation and contrast between the candidates
The three candidates represent very different visions: Mamdani, the favorite according to polls, pushes a progressive agenda with a rent freeze, free day care and other proposals that raised controversy; Cuomo defends his executive experience and seeks to reposition himself after his political fall amid harassment cases; and Sliwa, founder of the Guardian Angels, promises more police and a tough hand against crime.
LATEST
