
A federal judge in Massachusetts on Monday struck down a regulation pushed by the administration of President Donald Trump that sought to limit the stay of foreign students in the United States, regardless of the duration of their academic programs.
The decision, handed down by Federal Judge F. Dennis Saylor, who was appointed during the presidency of George W. Bush, represents a legal setback for one of the immigration measures of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) aimed at tightening control over holders of student and exchange visitor visas.
As reported by Just the News, the judge ruled that the regulation was "arbitrary and capricious," concluding that DHS had not adequately assessed its costs and benefits nor sufficiently justified the need to replace the previous system.
What did the regulation establish?
The regulation, published in July 2026, sought to replace the system known as "duration of status," which allows foreign students to remain in the country legally as long as they maintain their immigration status and make normal progress in their studies.
The new provision established admission periods of up to four years for F and J visa holders. Students, researchers and professors whose programs required more time were required to apply for an extension of stay with immigration authorities.
DHS defended the changes as a tool to prevent immigration fraud, strengthen national security and improve oversight of foreign nationals temporarily admitted to the country.
However, Judge Saylor determined that the agency had not sufficiently demonstrated that the new renewal mechanism was more effective in combating potential irregularities, nor that its benefits justified the consequences of abandoning the current system.
Lawsuit filed by educational organizations
The decision stems from a lawsuit filed in August by a coalition of educational organizations and unions, including NAFSA and the Presidents' Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration.
The plaintiffs argued that the restrictions would create uncertainty among international students, hinder the continuity of their academic programs, and affect the ability of American universities to attract foreign talent.
The court had already temporarily suspended the regulation's implementation in September, before it took effect. The Nov. 16 ruling went further by formally striking down the regulation under the Administrative Procedure Act.
Arrivals of new international students drop 15%
The court ruling coincides with the release of new data showing a decline in international enrollment at American universities.
According to the Institute of International Education (IIE), new enrollments of international students fell by 15% in the fall of 2026, while total international enrollment decreased by 9% among the institutions surveyed.
The report, based on information from 809 institutions of higher education, is being released amid the Trump administration's efforts to tighten immigration controls and the conditions under which foreigners may remain in the country.
For now, the court ruling keeps the previous system in place, allowing international students to continue their academic programs as long as they comply with the legal requirements of their immigration status.
However, the federal government can still appeal the ruling, so the dispute over restrictions on student visas could continue in court.


