Skip to content
Friday, November 20, 2026No spin. Just news.
Society

Court rejects appeal of Democratic congresswoman accused of assaulting ICE agents

Rep. LaMonica McIver faces federal charges stemming from a confrontation that took place in May 2025 outside an immigration detention center in New Jersey. The court's ruling allows the criminal proceedings to continue on two of the three charges filed against her.

Diane HernándezPublished · 4 minutes read
Court rejects appeal of Democratic congresswoman accused of assaulting ICE agents
A Department of Homeland Security (DHS) building

A federal appeals court on Thursday rejected Democratic Rep. LaMonica McIver's request to reconsider a court ruling allowing criminal proceedings against her to continue following a confrontation with federal immigration agents in New Jersey.

The Third Circuit Court of Appeals denied her request for a new hearing before the original panel of judges and before the full court, thereby upholding an August ruling that denied McIver's legislative immunity with respect to two of the three federal charges she faces.

According to the court order issued on Nov. 19, only three of the 13 judges who participated in the review supported the representative's request.

The decision marks another setback for McIver, who represents New Jersey's 10th District. She maintains that the Department of Justice is targeting her for her oversight of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), according to Breitbart News.

What happened at the ICE detention center?

The case dates back to May 9, 2025, when McIver and two other members of the House of Representatives went to inspect the Delaney Hall federal immigration detention center, located in Newark, N.J.

During the visit, a confrontation broke out between federal agents, protesters and elected officials after authorities attempted to arrest Newark Mayor Ras Baraka, who was also in the vicinity of the facility.

According to the indictment filed by the Department of Justice, McIver allegedly physically interfered with the agents who were attempting to make the arrest.

Prosecutors contend that the congresswoman struck a federal agent with her forearm while trying to prevent the mayor's arrest and that she subsequently used both arms to strike another officer as she was returning to the restricted area.

Baraka was initially detained, although federal authorities ultimately dropped the charge of illegal entry brought against him.

McIver has rejected the allegations and maintains that her actions were part of the oversight responsibilities incumbent upon members of Congress.

Court rejects legislative immunity argument

The congresswoman's defense team had sought to have the charges dismissed by invoking the constitutional clause known as the "Speech or Debate Clause," which protects federal lawmakers from certain legal proceedings related to the performance of their duties.

However, in a ruling issued on Aug. 26, 2026, a three-judge panel concluded, by a two-to-one majority, that this protection did not extend to the physical conduct attributed to McIver during the agents' intervention.

The court distinguished between the inspection visit—recognized as a protected legislative activity, and the actions allegedly committed during the mayor's arrest.

The ruling allowed the first two charges to stand and ordered a lower court to reexamine the possible application of legislative immunity to the third charge.

With Thursday's decision, the judges refused to reconsider that ruling.

As explained by Roll Call, McIver could still appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.

McIver could face up to 17 years in prison

According to the Department of Justice, the three charges originally filed against the congresswoman carry a combined maximum sentence of 17 years in prison.

The two charges that may proceed following the appeals court's decision carry maximum sentences of eight years each, while the third carries a sentence of up to one year in prison.

In a statement posted on her official website, the representative accused the Department of Justice of using the judicial system to punish her for overseeing ICE's activities.

McIver warned that the ruling could set a dangerous precedent for the independence of Congress and stated that her legal team is evaluating the available options.

As reported by The New Jersey Monitor, the congresswoman believes the case is part of a political witch hunt driven by the administration of President Donald Trump.

Legal proceedings will continue

The Third Circuit Court's decision does not constitute a guilty verdict, but it clears one of the main legal obstacles that McIver's defense team had raised in an attempt to halt the proceedings.

The case will continue in federal court, while the review of the third charge in the lower court remains pending.

The controversy has also sparked a debate over the limits of congressional immunity and the authority of federal agents during inspections conducted by members of Congress at immigration detention facilities.

Related topics